11 Comments
User's avatar
Marian Blazes's avatar

Bagel Barn near Princeton - the best!!

Expand full comment
Marian Blazes's avatar

it meets all the criteria - including the mural. I think there's a nail salon in the strip mall right next door to it. (but technically it's between a cell phone repair place and a martial arts studio :-) )

Expand full comment
Sean Keeley's avatar

Nail salon two businesses over. Done!

Expand full comment
Diane Davis's avatar

Sussex County is way out of your way but Hamburg Hot Bagels in (yes) Hamburg NJ off Rte 23 makes a pretty good bagel. And did you know there’s an Ess-a-Bagel near the Alaska Airlines gates at Newark Airport?

Expand full comment
Diane Davis's avatar

It’s in a 2-building strip mall and there is a nail salon and a liquor store in the other building.

Expand full comment
Sean Keeley's avatar

Nail salon in a strip mall...it can't be bad! And I did not know that about Ess-a-Bagel. I'll keep an eye out!

Expand full comment
Diane Davis's avatar

Re Ess-a-Bagel, I misspoke— it’s actually at United gates, not Alaska, near gate A-16.

Expand full comment
Sean Keeley's avatar

I was in A on my flight back. I looked for it and it was on the exact other side of the terminal, so I didn't get to it. Next time!

Expand full comment
Julia's avatar

I have fond memories of O-Bagel in Stirling but it's been 20 years.

Expand full comment
David Powell's avatar

Gotta try Bagels-4U in Bernardsville!

Expand full comment
Sean Keeley's avatar

So here are my reader recommendations for potential NJ bagel reviews so far...

Hamburg Hot Bagels (Hamburg)

Bagels-4U (Bernardsville)

O'Bagel (Stirling)

Teaneck Road Hot Bagels (Teaneck)

Bagel Oven (Red Bank)

Hot Bagel Bakery (Oakhurst)

Bagel Nook (Freehold)

Keep the recs coming!

Expand full comment